Old Flame Brewing Company — ranked #1
#01 · Old Flame Brewing Company
← All topics
OntariodrinkFeatured

Best Brewery in Ontario

From taprooms to bottle shops.

10 businesses ranked·Ranked by a free score weighted toward customer satisfaction & service·Last reviewed: · refreshed monthly

Neighbourhood map

10 pinned
  1. 01
    Old Flame Brewing Company

    Old Flame Brewing Company

    • Google rating of 4.8 from 190 reviews indicates high customer satisfaction.
    • Yelp rating also 4.8, showcasing consistent quality across platforms.
    • Reviewers praise the inviting atmosphere and friendly staff.
    • Popular for its laid-back vibe and live music events.
    • Offers a variety of beers with fair prices and good snacks.
    📍 43 Tank House Lane, Toronto, ON M5A 3C4, Canada4.8 (190)(416) 360-1209website ↗
    71
    Ranking score
  2. 02
    Muddy York Brewing Co.

    Muddy York Brewing Co.

    • 4.8 Google rating from 364 reviews highlights exceptional quality.
    • Award-winning craft beers praised by loyal customers.
    • Friendly staff and cozy atmosphere enhance the experience.
    • Regular events and food popups attract a vibrant community.
    • Family-run business with strong customer satisfaction.
    📍 50 Innovator Ave Unit #1, Whitchurch-Stouffville, ON L4A 0Y2, Canada4.8 (364)(416) 619-7819website ↗
    63
    Ranking score
  3. 03
    Bickford Brewing Company

    Bickford Brewing Company

    • Perfect 5.0 rating on Google from 64 reviews.
    • Exceptional customer satisfaction at 95th percentile.
    • Variety of brews praised for fitting any mood.
    • Welcoming staff creates a homey atmosphere.
    • Regular events enhance the community experience.
    📍 292a Harbord St, Toronto, ON M6G 1G6, Canada5 (64)website ↗
    63
    Ranking score
  4. 04
    Badlands Brewing Company

    Badlands Brewing Company

    • Google rating of 4.8 from 231 reviews highlights customer satisfaction.
    • Excellent outdoor space praised for its beauty and maintenance.
    • Known for exceptional hazy IPAs, attracting beer enthusiasts.
    • Offers live music and food trucks, enhancing weekend experiences.
    • Family-friendly environment with space for kids to play.
    📍 13926 Chinguacousy Rd, Inglewood, ON L7C 1Z3, Canada4.8 (231)website ↗
    60
    Ranking score
  5. 05
    Black Lab Brewing

    Black Lab Brewing

    • 4.8 Google rating from 498 reviews highlights excellent customer satisfaction.
    • Impeccable service praised by multiple reviewers, enhancing the overall experience.
    • Dog-friendly environment attracts pet owners, creating a welcoming atmosphere.
    • Variety of beers available, catering to diverse tastes and preferences.
    • Responsive to large group reservations, ensuring accommodating service.
    📍 818 Eastern Ave, Toronto, ON M4L 1A1, Canada4.8 (498)(647) 352-2525website ↗
    53
    Ranking score
  6. 06
    Bench Brewing Company

    Bench Brewing Company

    • Google rating of 4.7 from 2313 reviews indicates high customer satisfaction.
    • Unique venue in a restored historic school adds charm to the experience.
    • Reviewers praise the delicious craft beer and food options.
    • Popular choice in Niagara's wine country, enhancing local tours.
    • Yelp rating of 4.2 from 54 reviews supports consistent quality.
    📍 3991 King St, Beamsville, ON L3J 1E7, Canada4.7 (2313)(905) 562-3991website ↗
    49
    Ranking score
  7. 07
    Steadfast Brewing Company

    Steadfast Brewing Company

    • Google rating of 4.8 from 173 reviews indicates high customer satisfaction.
    • Yelp rating of 4.3 with 59 reviews highlights quality service and atmosphere.
    • Reviewers praise the friendly staff and welcoming vibe of the brewery.
    • Offers a variety of beers, including crisp Kölsch and bold IPAs.
    • Affordable growler refills make it a great value for local patrons.
    📍 301 Lansdowne Ave, Toronto, ON M6K 2W5, Canada4.8 (173)(416) 343-9595website ↗
    44
    Ranking score
  8. 08
    Lost Craft Brewery (Canary District)

    Lost Craft Brewery (Canary District)

    • 4.6 Google rating from 95 reviews highlights customer satisfaction.
    • Popular for delicious food, especially the spicy fried chicken sandwich.
    • Offers free pool, dog-friendly patio, and a trivia night.
    • Warm, welcoming staff praised for efficiency and service quality.
    • Daily happy hour with affordable apps enhances the experience.
    📍 482 Front St E, Toronto, ON M5A 0S8, Canada4.6 (95)(416) 366-6010website ↗
    41
    Ranking score
  9. 09
    Brewing at the Market

    Brewing at the Market

    • Google rating of 5.0 from 4 reviews.
    • Yelp rating of 4.4 with 455 reviews.
    • Highly praised for amazing craft beer selection.
    • Offers food from the market to enjoy on-site.
    • Known for friendly staff and great customer experience.
    📍 91 Front St E Market Street, and, The Esplanade entrance, Toronto, ON M5E 1C3, Canada5 (4)(437) 918-9115website ↗
    35
    Ranking score
  10. 10
    Woodhouse Brewing Co.

    Woodhouse Brewing Co.

    • Google rating of 3.9 from 19 reviews.
    • Yelp rating of 4.3 from 18 reviews.
    • Praised for unique Art Deco architecture.
    • Beer quality highlighted as fantastic by customers.
    • Strong digital presence with high visibility.
    📍 150 Symes Rd, Old Toronto, ON M6N 0B1, Canada3.9 (19)(416) 766-1616website ↗
    23
    Ranking score

The buyer's guide

What makes a great drink

The Hunt for Ontario's Best Brewery

What makes a great drink

A truly outstanding beer, the kind that elevates a brewery from good to great, starts with impeccable ingredients. We're talking high-quality malt, expressive hops, and clean, consistent water. Beyond raw materials, precision in brewing technique is paramount. This means meticulous temperature control, careful fermentation management, and consistent carbonation. A great brewery also demonstrates innovation and variety, offering a diverse tap list that caters to different palates while still excelling at classic styles. Finally, the overall experience, from the knowledgeable staff who can guide your choices to an inviting atmosphere, significantly contributes to the perception of a "best" brewery. It's not just about the liquid; it's about the entire occasion.

What to look for

  • Diverse Tap List: Look for a range of styles – lagers, IPAs, stouts, sours – indicating breadth of skill and appeal.
  • Small Batch Offerings: These often showcase experimentation and unique, limited-time brews.
  • On-Site Food Options: While not strictly about the drink, a good food pairing elevates the experience and shows commitment to customer comfort.
  • Flight Options: The ability to sample several beers is crucial for discovery and determining personal preferences.
  • Growler/Can Sales: Convenient for taking your favorites home and a sign of customer-centric service.
  • Brewery Tours/Visibility: Seeing the brewing operation can be a sign of transparency and pride in their craft.
  • Ambiance: Does the space feel welcoming, clean, and conducive to enjoying a beverage?
  • Staff Knowledge: Are the bartenders able to articulate the characteristics of each beer and offer informed recommendations?

Local context in Ontario

Ontario's craft beer scene is vibrant and diverse, with breweries ranging from small-town operations to large, established players. Prices for a pint typically range from $7-$10, with specialty or higher ABV beers sometimes exceeding this. Locals highly value fresh, often seasonal, offerings and a strong connection to agricultural roots, with many breweries highlighting local hop or fruit sourcing.

Questions to ask

  • "What's new on tap that you're particularly excited about right now?"
  • "Do you have any beers brewed with local Ontario ingredients?"
  • "Can you recommend a beer that's approachable for someone new to craft beer?"
  • "What's your most popular beer, and why do you think people love it?"
  • "Do you offer any educational experiences or tours of the brewing process?"